Skip to main content

Originally published November 9, 2012 at 4:30 PM | Page modified November 9, 2012 at 4:30 PM

  • Share:
  • Comments (10)
  • Print

Editorial: Controversial octopus kill should lead to sensible policy

Some members of the public have overreacted to a 19-year-old diver’s recent, legal hunt. It’s time to learn from this experience and let the state do its job.

Seattle Times Editorial

Most Popular Comments
Hide / Show comments
divers and others upset about the incident should forgive his inexperience He may be... MORE
As a modern society, we have become disconnected from the harvesting and killing of... MORE
Judging from Captain Weird's comment and the vitriol spewed by a bunch of other... MORE


THE Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife is poised to flex its regulatory tentacles in the aftermath of a controversial hunt in Seacrest Park, a divers’ haven in West Seattle and home to the world’s largest octopus species.


Nineteen-year-old Dylan Mayer didn’t break any laws when he caught and harvested a Pacific octopus on Halloween Day.

But he broke a code understood by most other divers familiar with the area: The Pacific octopus is a beloved underwater creature that should be viewed, but not killed.

The community-college student was confronted on the beach by a more experienced diver. Several images of the octopus — with its limp tentacles dangling over the hunter’s arms — went viral on the Internet.

According to Seattle Times news stories, Mayer’s mother has received threats against her son.

In an effort to add a bit of levity to a serious situation, she has responded to the barrage of phone calls at their Maple Valley home by calling herself “Octo-Mom.”

A little “squid pro quo” ought to quell the overreaction to this sea tale.

Mayer regrets the episode and has publicly expressed his remorse. Humbled following a week of criticism and getting nicknamed “octopus boy” by diving bloggers, he personally appeared before the Fish and Wildlife Commission this week to call for a ban on harvesting giant octopus at the site where he was caught in action.

He reportedly told the panel, “I didn’t know they were so beloved, or I wouldn’t have done it.”

In turn, divers and others upset about the incident should forgive his inexperience.

The department should develop a sensible policy, whether that means placing some limits on harvesting or designating certain areas as marine preserves.

 Subscribe today!

Subscribe today!

99¢ for four weeks of unlimited digital access.



NDN Video

The Seattle Times Historical Archives

Browse our newspaper page archives from 1900-1984