Originally published Friday, September 23, 2011 at 10:00 PM

Jobs, amenities help neighborhood hold value

Single most important determinate of real estate prices in an area is employment opportunity nearby.

No comments have been posted to this article.


Buying a home that declines sharply in property value can put you underwater on your mortgage, erode your net worth and leave you unable to relocate for a new job or adapt to a change in household income. And one of the biggest factors that determines whether a home will rise or fall in value is its neighborhood.

That's actually a good thing, because you don't need a crystal ball to evaluate a neighborhood's direction, says Andrew Shiller, creator of, a real-estate research website based in Worcester, Mass.

"The places that tend to hold on to their value are places that basically do well across two primary dimensions that anyone can think about and evaluate neighborhoods by," Shiller says.

Those two criteria and a few others can help you get a sense of where a neighborhood is headed.

The single most important determinate of real-estate prices in an area is employment opportunity nearby, Shiller says. Without that, a neighborhood is at risk of taking a free-fall in real-estate values.

"How convenient is this to a lot of high-paying jobs? That is the most important thing for value,"he says.

There are a few telltale signs of areas with long-term opportunities for jobs, Shiller says.

• Low unemployment.

• High household income.

• Seats of federal or state government.

• Creative industries (music, television, design, publishing, advertising).

• Research facilities.

• Large or prominent colleges and universities.

Shiller says the Bureau of Labor Statistics has a wealth of information that can help you assess an area's employment picture. One key bureau feature is the Local Area Unemployment Statistics map, which can give unemployment information by metro area and county. Another data set called the Current Employment Statistics can tell you how many people are employed in different sectors of the economy in a given metro area.

Having desirable amenities within the neighborhood is a second major factor in whether a neighborhood will appreciate or decline in property value, Shiller says.

In the world of real-estate, "amenity" is the term used to describe any asset within a community that people find desirable.

Shiller cites some examples of key amenities that can add value to a neighborhood:

• Low crime.

• Good public schools.

• Parks.

• Pleasing views.

• Distinctive architecture.

• A variety of retail stores.

• An educated population.

Still, popular amenities by themselves aren't a guarantee that property value will remain high, Shiller says.

"When a high proportion of the value of real estate is based on amenities and not access to job opportunities, it is more vulnerable to collapse," Shiller says.

Doing a drive-through of a prospective neighborhood is a good way to get a gut feeling for where a neighborhood is now and where it's headed, says Ken Shuman, a spokesman for real-estate information site

"Look at the neighbor's lawns. Look at the neighbors' houses," Shuman says. "Do they take care of them?

Shuman also has one caveat for conducting the drive-through test: No test is complete without a drive-through at night.

"You usually go to open houses in the afternoon or in the morning, so definitely drive through the neighborhood in the evening," Shuman says. "This is a big mistake a lot of people make, because they see it on a sunny Sunday afternoon and they think it's a gorgeous area."

Shiller says the neighborhoods that protect homeowners' value the most are those that combine good job opportunities and amenities in ways that are unusual for the area.

For instance, if you live in or around a metro area with poor schools overall, buying in a neighborhood that has good schools can keep your property values high.

Shiller cites the examples of Belle Meade in Nashville, Tenn., and Beverly Hills, Calif., both of which enjoy the access to opportunities of nearby urban centers, but also have amenities like excellent public schools and low crime that set them apart.

"These places just go out of control as far as value,"he says.

Consistently rising home values over the long term is a key sign a neighborhood will protect residential property value. The critical phrase there is "long term," Shiller says.

He says looking at recent numbers can be misleading, especially since they're likely to be heavily influenced by the recent boom and bust in the housing markets.

"You don't want to look at only one quarter. One quarter can tell you, 'Is it raining today or is it sunny today?' " he says. "But that really doesn't tell you about the climate. You want to know, 'Does it rain all the time here?' "

To do that, he advises potential homebuyers to look at property values and comparables going back at regular intervals over the past 20 years, predating the housing bubble.

"When some people look at the last 10 years, some areas look like they went crazy high," he says. "And when you look at the last two years, they look like they fell through the floor because they bubbled."

News where, when and how you want it

Email Icon


NDN Video